I'm sorta middle of the road too, although a bit more towards the "meh" lane. :p I just wasn't wowed and it feels pretty obvious now that Moffat is going to be more about fun and silly rather than emotional impact and storylines that make somewhat sense. Which is fine, I like that too, but that puts Doctor Who with Psych and Leverage rather than True Blood and Farscape.
I like 11 too, and Amy, although I'm still neutral to Rory and hate River Song. But I'm not connecting with it like I used to, so that's sad. Think it's time I rewatched s1-4 again.